Skip to content
All comparisons

Sprain vs Fracture

By the AllHealth UK editorial teamLast reviewed Next review due Compiled from published NHS and NICE guidance. Not reviewed by a clinician.

Is it a sprain or a broken bone?

You often cannot tell without an X-ray — the NHS says a badly sprained wrist can be hard to tell apart from a break. Being able to put weight on it does not rule out a break — many broken ankles and wrists can still be walked or moved on. Suspect a fracture if the pain is severe, you cannot use the limb at all, or it has changed shape. Get any suspected break checked.

Immediate action required: call 999 or go to A&E if

  • A bone is sticking out through the skin
  • The limb has changed shape or is at an odd angle
  • The limb is numb, tingling, or has pins and needles
  • There is a bad cut that is bleeding heavily
  • You heard a crack when you had the injury
  • The skin around the injury looks blue or grey, or feels cold to touch

If you are weighing up whether it is bad enough to call, that is itself a reason to call. Nobody is annoyed by a 999 call that turns out to be the less serious of the two.

Sprain or Strain compared with Fracture (Broken Bone)
FeatureSprain or StrainFracture (Broken Bone)
Typical signs
  • Pain and tenderness around a joint
  • Swelling and bruising building over hours
  • Pain, tenderness or weakness around the joint
  • Muscle spasm or cramping
  • Steadily improves day by day
  • Severe pain that is not settling
  • Pain severe enough that you cannot use the limb normally
  • Visible change in shape or angle
  • Numbness, tingling or pins and needles
  • Only an X-ray can confirm it
How long it lastsMost feel better after 2 weeks; avoid strenuous exercise for up to 8 weeksA broken arm or wrist usually takes 6 to 8 weeks to heal
What helpsPRICE for the first 2 to 3 days — protection, rest, ice, compression, elevation — plus paracetamolUrgent treatment centre or A&E for an X-ray; usually a plaster cast or splint
What to doSelf-care at homeCall 999 now

Sources and further reading

This page was written from the following published guidance. All links checked 26 August 2026.

Read about the symptom

Other things people mix up